We visit the factory before the design is frozen, not after. On a full development project that means a trip at the end of the Develop phase, with a working prototype in a suitcase, to the two or three suppliers on the shortlist.
The trip for the Velora C1 is the one we still talk about. Our drawing showed a welded aluminium frame with 14 tube joints. We went to see a frame welder and a foundry in the same week. On the foundry floor the toolmaker looked at the steering head, where five tubes met, and asked why it was not a single casting. Redrawn as one gravity-cast node, it removed six welds and a welding jig, and took $41 off the unit cost of the frame.
What we look at
The reject bin: what is in it, and how full it is.
The oldest machine still running, and what runs on it.
Who does incoming inspection, and with which gauge.
How finished parts are packed for the lorry.
Whether the person quoting has ever stood at the line.

The first cast node from the foundry, beside the welded prototype it replaced.
A drawing sent by email gets a quote. A prototype put on a toolmaker’s bench gets opinions, and the opinions are worth more: a draft angle one degree too tight, a rib that will leave a sink mark, a screw the operator cannot reach with the driver they really use. We come home with a list of 30 to 50 changes. Most are small, and together they are the difference between a tool that runs and a tool that is reworked twice.
Ask the toolmaker what they would change. Then be quiet for a while.

Written by
Santiago Reyes
Mechanical engineer
Spends about six weeks a year on factory floors and comes back with better drawings.


